What happens when an AI agent pays for something and the cardholder says they never ordered it? The same thing that happens with any other card payment, to begin with. Stripe's definition does not change for agents: "A dispute (also known as a chargeback) occurs when a cardholder questions your payment with their card issuer", and the issuer's dispute "immediately reverses the payment."
An agent's card payment falls under the same dispute rules as any other card payment, with one new question attached: can you show that this agent was who it claimed to be, and that the shopper approved this order? The card networks, AP2 and Stripe have each published a way to answer it, and some are still early: as of November 2026, Stripe labels its shared payment tokens "Public preview" and AP2's specification is at v0.2. None of them publishes a fraud or chargeback rate for agent orders, so nobody can honestly tell you whether agent orders are riskier than other orders yet. We will not guess either.
It helps to separate the risks first, because each one has a different answer.