Take the llms.txt file off a site and run Chrome's Lighthouse on it, and the llms.txt audit does not fail. Its documentation says a missing file is marked "Not Applicable (N/A), as providing the file is optional at the moment." Lighthouse looks for the file and is perfectly relaxed when it isn't there.
So, does llms.txt work? For Google Search, no: Google says Search "ignores them" and that a file "will neither harm nor help". For AI assistants, nobody knows from first-party sources, because none of the vendors whose crawler pages we read says its bots read a site's llms.txt. The file is cheap, optional and harmless, and the evidence that it changes anything for a store is thin.
If you have already decided to publish a file, our llms.txt guide covers what a store's should hold, with a builder. This piece weighs the evidence instead, starting with the proposal's own claims.